Calm navy-blue lake at dusk with soft horizon — symbolizing clarity, wellness, and peaceful healthcare alternatives.

Health Shares vs Insurance

How Health Shares Are Similar to Traditional Health Insurance

  1. They Support Medical Costs
    Both models help members manage and pay for healthcare expenses like doctor visits, hospital stays, surgeries, lab tests, and more.
  2. They Often Involve a Monthly Payment
    Health shares have a monthly “share amount” (similar to a premium) that members contribute toward the community funds.
  3. They Use a Form of Cost Sharing
    Just like insurance has deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, health shares have concepts like Personal Responsibility Amounts (PRAs) or Member Responsibility Amounts.
  4. There Are Guidelines About What’s Eligible
    Both models have rules about what types of care or conditions are included (though health share memberships call them “shareable expenses”).

How Health Shares Are Different from Traditional Insurance

  1. They’re Not Insurance
    Health shares are not legally considered insurance. They are voluntary associations where members agree to help with each other’s medical expenses.
  2. No Network Restrictions (Usually)
    Many health shares allow you to see any licensed doctor or provider which means that you’re not locked into a specific insurance network.
  3. More Flexibility, Fewer Bureaucratic Rules
    Members often find it easier to manage costs and navigate care without insurance red tape (e.g. pre-authorizations, denials, network disputes).
  4. Religious or Lifestyle Expectations
    Some health shares (like Christian ministries) have faith-based requirements. Others, like Knew Health, are more secular and emphasize healthy lifestyles instead.
  5. No Guarantee of Payment
    Since they’re not insurance, there’s no legal obligation to pay your medical bills. However, reputable memberships like Knew Health have strong track records of reliably sharing costs.
  6. May Not Support Preventive or Routine Care
    Unlike ACA-compliant insurance, health shares might not support things like annual physicals, birth control, or pre-existing conditions (at least not right away).
  7. Portability & International Access
    Health shares can be a great option for travelers and expats as many share in emergencies internationally, which traditional U.S. insurance often does not.
Doctor smiling in clinic — representing quality care available through health share plans like KnewHealth.

🔍 Key Differences between Health Shares and Traditional Insurance Plans

FeatureHealth SharesTraditional Insurance
Monthly CostLowerHigher
Legally Required CoverageNoYes (under ACA)
Network RestrictionsUsually NoneYes
Access AbroadOften IncludedRare
Legal Guarantee to PayNo (but reliable plans do)Yes
Encourages Healthy LifestyleYesNot typically

🧠 So, Is a Health Share Right for You?

A health share could be a great fit if you:

  • Are generally healthy and don’t need frequent care
  • Want lower monthly costs than insurance
  • Prefer to choose your own doctors
  • Like the idea of a community-based, ethical model
  • Travel frequently or live abroad (plans like Knew Health offer international access)
  • Want to have a safety net as a self-pay patient

👉 Learn More About Knew Health Membership

*use promo code “JENNY30” for 30% off 1st 6 months

*Terms and Conditions: Available for new members who have never been members of Knew Health previously. Cannot be combined with any other offers or promotions. After the six month promotional period, the Knew Health membership will automatically renew at the regular membership rate. Knew Health reserves the right to modify or cancel this offer at any time without prior notice.

Affiliate Disclaimer

Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase—at no additional cost to you. Please know that I only recommend products and services that I personally use, trust, and genuinely believe will bring value to my audience. Your support through these links helps me keep this site running and continue sharing helpful content. Thank you!